In this guide, we compare medicine cabinets vs open shelving to help you decide which one fits your bathroom remodeling best.
???? Medicine Cabinets: Compact, Concealed Storage
A medicine cabinet is typically mounted above the sink or recessed into the wall. It often doubles as a mirror, making it a practical 2-in-1 solution.
✅ Pros:
- Hidden storage keeps counters clutter-free
- Ideal for daily-use items like toothpaste, meds, and skincare
- Many come with mirrors and built-in lighting
- Lockable models offer safety for homes with kids
❌ Cons:
- Limited in size—may not hold larger items
- Recessed options require wall modifications
- Can feel bulky in minimalist or small bathrooms
???? Best For: Minimalists, small bathrooms, or anyone who prefers a tidy, hidden look.
???? Open Shelving: Stylish and Accessible
Open shelves provide storage and display space and are often mounted on walls above the toilet, sink, or bathtub.
✅ Pros:
- Visually opens up small bathrooms
- Great for displaying décor, rolled towels, or baskets
- Easy to install and rearrange
- Encourages organization since everything is visible
❌ Cons:
- Can look cluttered if not styled well
- Requires regular dusting and upkeep
- Not ideal for private or unattractive items (e.g., medication, razors)
???? Best For: Design-forward bathrooms, larger spaces, or users who enjoy styling their space.
???? So, Which Should You Choose?
| Criteria | Medicine Cabinet | Open Shelving |
|---|---|---|
| Space-saving | ✅ Compact & efficient | ⚠️ Takes more wall space |
| Privacy & security | ✅ Enclosed & lockable | ❌ Items are exposed |
| Design appeal | ⚠️ Functional but basic | ✅ Decorative & customizable |
| Ease of installation | ⚠️ May require wall cutting | ✅ Simple to install |
| Best for small items | ✅ Perfect for daily essentials | ⚠️ Requires containers or trays |
????️ Pro Tip: Use Both for a Balanced Solution
You don’t have to choose just one. Many modern bathrooms use:
- A medicine cabinet for personal items
- Open shelves for display, towels, and baskets
Combining both gives you the benefits of concealed storage and decorative flair.
Final Thoughts
Both medicine cabinets and open shelving have their place in a well-designed bathroom. If you prefer a clean, hidden look, a medicine cabinet is your best bet. But if you want easy access and a chance to show off your design style, open shelves might be the winner.